Chemical Equilibrium & SolubilityEquilibriumContent level: Core 18 min

The Reaction Quotient Q and Predicting Direction

What you'll be able to do: Calculate Q for any mixture and use the comparison with K to predict which way the reaction will proceed.

Introduction

Give a chemist a flask of reactants and products in arbitrary amounts and they can tell you which way it will go, without a rate law and without waiting. The tool is Q.

These are recommended, not required. You can start this lesson at any time.

Learning objectives

  • Write and evaluate Q for a mixture of arbitrary composition
  • Compare Q with K to predict the direction of change
  • Explain why Q equals K only at equilibrium
  • Apply Q to predict precipitation

Lesson

Same form, different moment

Q is built from the identical products-over-reactants expression, with the same exponents and the same exclusions for pure solids and liquids. The only difference is that Q uses current concentrations while K uses equilibrium ones.

Q = ([C] [D]) / ([A] [B]) at any instant

The three comparisons

If Q is smaller than K the product terms are too small, so the reaction must make more product and proceeds to the right. If Q is larger than K the reaction proceeds to the left. If Q equals K nothing changes.

Q < K: shift right. Q > K: shift left. Q = K: at equilibrium.

Why the rule works

Q moves continuously towards K as the reaction proceeds. Making product raises the numerator and lowers the denominator, so Q always increases when the reaction runs forward. The system therefore travels in whichever direction closes the gap.

Q with pure reactants or products

A mixture of only reactants has Q = 0, which is below any positive K, so the reaction must go forward. A mixture of only products has Q infinite, so it must go in reverse. These limiting cases are a quick sanity check on any Q calculation.

Q in solubility problems

For a dissolving salt the same quotient is written from the ion concentrations and compared with Ksp. If Q exceeds Ksp the solution is supersaturated and a precipitate forms; below Ksp everything stays dissolved. This is the standard way to answer will a precipitate form.

Q > Ksp means precipitate; Q < Ksp means no precipitate.

Key ideas

Definition
Reaction quotient Q

The products-over-reactants expression evaluated with the concentrations present at a given moment.

Rule
Q < K

The reaction proceeds forward, making more product.

Rule
Q > K

The reaction proceeds in reverse, making more reactant.

Rule
Q = K

The system is at equilibrium with no net change.

Key concept
Q and precipitation

Comparing Q with Ksp tells you whether a solid will appear.

Equation
Reaction quotient

Q = ([C] [D]) / ([A] [B])

  • [X] = current, not necessarily equilibrium, concentration

Worked examples

Worked example 1

For H(g) + I(g) ⇌ 2 HI(g), K = 50.0. A flask holds [H] = 0.20 M, [I] = 0.20 M, [HI] = 0.40 M. Which way does the reaction proceed?

Try it first: Write the quotient with the numbers you were given before comparing anything.

    0 of 4 steps revealed.

    Worked example 2

    For NO(g) ⇌ 2 NO(g), Kp = 0.15 atm. A vessel contains P(NO) = 0.10 atm and P(NO) = 0.50 atm. Predict the direction.

    Try it first: Note that Kp is used with pressures, so Q must be built from pressures too.

      0 of 3 steps revealed.

      Worked example 3

      Equal volumes of 0.0020 M Pb(NO) and 0.0020 M NaCl are mixed. Ksp for PbCl is 1.7 × 10⁻⁵. Does a precipitate form?

      Try it first: Remember that mixing equal volumes halves every concentration.

        0 of 4 steps revealed.

        Common mistakes

        Using K in place of Q for a non-equilibrium mixture.

        Why it's wrong: K only describes the equilibrium state; the current mixture may be far from it.

        Check instead: Evaluate Q with the given concentrations and then compare.

        Getting the direction backwards when Q < K.

        Why it's wrong: A small Q means too little product, so product must be made.

        Check instead: Ask which side needs to grow for Q to rise to K.

        Forgetting dilution when two solutions are mixed.

        Why it's wrong: Every concentration changes on mixing, often by a factor of two.

        Check instead: Recalculate each concentration for the combined volume first.

        Including a solid when writing Q.

        Why it's wrong: Q follows exactly the same exclusion rules as K.

        Check instead: Drop every (s) and (l) term.

        Practice this skill

        No practice questions are available for this topic yet. You can still practice the whole unit.

        What you should now know

        The reaction quotient Q has exactly the same algebraic form as K, but is evaluated with whatever concentrations or pressures the mixture happens to have right now. Comparing Q with K predicts the direction of change: Q < K means there is too little product, so the reaction runs forward; Q > K means too much product, so it runs in reverse; Q = K means the system is already at equilibrium. Because Q and K are computed the same way, any error in the expression affects both, so writing the expression carefully once solves both problems. Q is also the tool used to decide whether a precipitate forms in a solubility problem.

        • Q uses the same expression as K but current concentrations
        • Q < K shifts right, Q > K shifts left
        • Q = K means equilibrium
        • Only reactants gives Q = 0, so the reaction must go forward
        • Q versus Ksp decides whether a precipitate forms

        Sources and further reading

        This lesson is original Chem Help content. No external sources were adapted.